And the Mountains Echoed by Khaled Hosseini : Book Review



All things considered, there was Three Cups of Tea and what a calamity that ended up being! Greg Mortenson and David Oliver Relin‘s 2007 record of how medical caretaker cum-mountain climber Mortenson turned into a humane focused on enhancing the part of young ladies in Pakistan and Afghanistan clung to the New York Times true to life success rundown for four years—until writer Jon Krakauer (Into the Wild, Into Thin Air) called foul, asserting the writers made up a percentage of the book’s most huge scenes.

Mortenson ended up being not such an adrenaline junky hazard taker all things considered, stunned bookworms and fans took in. He never endured as the casualty of an insane hijacking (a key occurrence in Three Cups) in a crazy area. Krakauer uncovered him to be just a top notch storyteller, and for that Mortenson needed to pay a soak value, which incorporated the boot from a philanthropy he’d set up to reserve schools in Pakistan and Afghanistan.

This story prompts a bigger point: From America’s family rooms, how would we advise where to draw the line between truth and fiction in such an inaccessible, unpredictable corner of the world?

The U.S.’s 12-year involvement in the area makes Afghanistan pretty much steady vicinity in our lives, yet what amount of do we truly know of the spot, its kin? A number of us can shake off in-the-news names like Kabul, Kandahar, Peshawar and Mazar-i-Sharif. We know the fear of the Taliban then and now—who hasn’t known about Malala Yousafzai, the daring Pakistani school young lady who took a Taliban projectile to her head? We’ve perused about the Afghan warlords, and even today, when the center of the U.s. has moved to different fronts (Syria, Libya), news still hails from Afghanistan peppered with stories of prisoner takings, kidnappings (Apparently Mortenson made his up, however they happen), and even decapitations.

It’s truth. These things happen. We chance depletion perusing of such viciousness. But then stories about Afghanistan keep on drawing in book fans not, I accept, on the grounds that they remind us in our cushy lives of the everyday dread and suppression that numerous individuals (ladies specifically) somewhere else face. We give careful consideration in light of the fact that these stories bring us something more human, deeper than features.

Take a gander at feel-great, genuine books like Kabul Beauty School: An American Woman Goes Behind the Veil, by Deborah Rodriguez. Then again Norwegian writer Asne Seierstad‘s The Bookseller of Kabul. Such books provide for us knowledge into the regular lives of customary Afghanis, and help us get a handle on why we try to be included in such a spot.


Fiction comes clean as well. Algerian essayist Yasmina Khadra‘s 2005 book, The Swallows of Kabul, recounts the story of two couples whose lives get enmeshed when the Taliban comes to power. Pakistani scholar Nadeem Aslam‘s 2009 artful culmination, A Wasted Vigil, portrays Afghans, Russians and Americans managing horrific severity, yet figuring out how to discover associations with each other.

Given all that is happened in Afghanistan in the previous 12 years, the rundown of fictional takes a shot at that nation ends up being thin. I finished a speedy Google hunt and thought of a rundown of simply twelve titles that compass a few decades of Afghan history. (These incorporate Ken Follett’s Lie down the Lions; CIA veteran Mitt Bearden’s Black Tulip: A Novel of War in Afghanistan; and James A. Michener’s 1963 creation, Caravans—a book that Jennifer Bryson, Visiting Research Professor in the Peacekeeping and Stability Operations Institute at the U.s. Armed force War College, refers to as prescribed perusing for anybody looking to get closer to Afghanis and Afghanistan through fiction.

Scornful book fans may release these books as intriguing misrepresentations, pandering to and facilitating the idea of Afghanistan as an equivocally wild place—one that will slip considerably further outside our ability to comprehend when U.S. troops retreat the nation at the end of 2014. Be that as it may, Bryson demands, these books help us comprehend Afghanis.  “A briefing book can tell us how women are treated in a particular region, or that some particular behavior will bring shame to a family,” she says. “But it won’t tell us what an ashamed man is worried about, or what a woman’s power in a clan feels like.”

To completely comprehend the individuals in Afghanistan then and given our country’s long inclusion there, a number of us have more than barely a craving to—we must comprehend their stories.

Enter the raconteur second to none of the Afghan story: Khaled Hosseini who created the top rated The Kite Runner (2003), a book that crossed over any barrier between abstract and mainstream fiction. Straightforward and wonderfully styled, the novel tugged at the deepest heartstrings of numerous Americans with no former feeling of Afghanistan as a spot or society.


No one does it very like Hosseini – his voice feels so dissimilar that one considers it Brand Hosseini. That brand may appear to be especially on presentation in the Afghan-conceived essayist’s new novel, And the Mountains Echoed. From the beginning look, the work may appear styled to rapidly turn into a Hollywood or even a Bollywood film.

The gaudy 300-page family adventure provides for us kin divided by condition, and then experiencing childhood in diverse conditions on distinctive landmasses. The pages overflow with all the components for an incredible tragedy for the silver screen: Families tore separated. Earth poor villagers, the chances stacked against them. A committed to-the-precise end servant. An Afghan warlord. A beguiling alcoholic Afghan émigré (who composes verse, to boot). Toss in a couple of French existentialists and a closeted gay man and begin the Polaroids rolling.


Hosseini draws up these characters in country and urban Afghanistan, additionally in Paris, on a Greek island, and off in sunny California. This geo-hopping smacks faintly of Danielle Steele, not minimum in light of the fact that Hosseini so energetically dishes out to groups of onlookers what they have developed to anticipate from him.

Thankfully, Hosseini is no Danielle Steele. What spares this new novel likewise spared his last, 2007’s A Thousand Splendid Suns, and pushed The Kite Runner to enduring victory: Hosseini’s rich, smoothly perused exposition.

In spite of the fact that the creator tells more than he demonstrates in this novel, his characteristic, straightforward sentences and moderate style tell stories of genuine individuals in a removed, yet true, land. It starts significant feelings and tweaks even the hardest of basic hearts.

And the Mountains Echoed begins with a story—a purposeful anecdote, really around a creature that takes youngsters from desperate villagers.

A stolen kid, the legend goes, will grow up with each possible extravagance and benefit and will never again need for anything. In return, however, the youngster loses something extremely profitable: The memory of its introduction to the world gang. That family, then again, will be reviled, always pining for its missing part.

Abdullah will pine in such a path for his sister, Pari, sold by her father to the affluent, egotistical, and ruined Nila Wahdati (the alcoholic Afghan excellence) to fill her empty, rather trivial life. The devoted servant Nabi, Pari’s uncle and the Wahdati family driver, handles the arrangement. We take in a mystery love for Nila drives the driver’s gesture: Despite the way that his adoration goes lonely, he feels forced to fill a void in Nila’s life by providing for her his niece.

Abdullah and Pari will encounter starkly distinctive lives outside Afghanistan as that nation experiences its troublesome history. One kin winds up running a kebab house in California. Alternate grows up encompassed by a cadre of Parisian intellectuals.

Sibling and sister will just meet years after the fact, when Abdullah has turned into an old, wiped out man who can no more even distinguish the individual he’s longed for his entire life. Pari can scarcely begin grappling with the way that a disintegrating geriatric with an unreliable memory truly is her sibling.

The story of And the Mountains Echoed moves from Afghanistan in the late 1940s to its post-Taliban/post-US intercession state. Blame makes plot. Nabi, the old driver (still alive), tries with the assistance of a Greek specialist working in the war-desolated area to assemble back the family he disjoined such a long time ago.

In now-recognizable Hosseini style, the spectator takes in every character’s story… the one real issue with this book. Things go simply a gnawed off kilter with the piece. Several stories appear to be totally unnecessary to the plot, and these drag this novel out more remote abroad than required.


Take the Greek specialist. Indeed a bad-to-the-bone Hosseini fan may be compelled to concede not requiring or needing his story.

One other scene takes after a few minor characters to no acceptable consummation. It sticks out of the novel as terribly and awkwardly as a sore thumb—perhaps just to let Hosseini get around to composing a horrific scene of a junior Afghani young lady whose uncle hacks her skull open with a hatchet.

Hosseini—a medicinal specialist by training was born in Afghanistan, and brought up in Paris and later the U.S. (His family gained political refuge here when the Soviets attacked their nation in 1980.) The creator does adoration to show in his books the mercilessness and wildness of present-day provincial Afghanistan. He exceeds expectations in demonstrating the smart and undignified routes individuals of Afghanistan arrangement with the substances of their circumstances. His written work dependably sparkles with a veritable affection for the nation of his introduction to the world.

A disgrace, then, that as a U.S. retreat from Afghanistan draws closer and another page of history holds to horses, we get negligible sights in this book of the extraordinary compassion Hosseini holds for that land and its kin.

All the more reason, then, to peruse books like Pakistani journalist Nadeem Aslam’s most recent, The Blind Man’s Garden, a book that arrangements at a deeper level than this unified with the passionate side of a ruthless war and a shaky peace. Also all the more motivation to trust Brand Hosseini will serve up an alternate book soon, this time with a bit less Bollywood out there.

Dibyendu Paul

Dibyendu is professionally a software engineer working with Tata Consultancy Services and one of the key founders of Rhododendron. He loves writingabout movies, quite fascinated about Cameras, he loves socializing.

Latest posts by Dibyendu Paul (see all)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *